Fractional CFO, business value
How to Increase the Value of a Home Service Business: What Drives It and Where to Start
For owners of HVAC, plumbing and other home service businesses who want the business to be worth more, whether or not a sale is on the horizon.
A home service business is worth more when a buyer or lender can count on its profit without the owner: clean books, profit the books can show, repeat revenue, no customer the business leans on, and a team and systems that run without the owner in every job. At Right Way Profits, Debbie DeKnight's fractional CFO service works on what the business is worth financially in its Growth and Scale levels. As a general starting point, get the books current, learn which numbers drive profit, then work on the drivers one at a time.
Last updated
What does "value" mean for an owner-run service business?
In general terms, what a buyer would pay for the business.
The equipment, vehicles and other assets count. So does the profit the business can keep producing after the owner steps back, which is what earnings-based methods look at. Most drivers on this page come back to one question from the buyer's side: how sure can I be that this profit continues without the person who built it?
How is a small business valued?
By more than one method. Of the five the SBA lists, three start from earnings or cash flow.
The U.S. Small Business Administration's guide to buying an existing business says "There are many different methods to determine a fair price for the sale of the business" and lists these:
| Method | How the SBA describes it |
|---|---|
| Capitalized earning approach | "refers to the return on the investment that the investor expects" |
| Excess earning method | "Like the capitalized earning method, except it separates return on assets from other earnings" |
| Cash flow method | "typically used to determine how much of a loan the business' cash flow can support" |
| Tangible assets (balance sheet) method | "values the business by the tangible assets" |
| Value of specific intangible assets method | "compares buying a wanted intangible asset versus creating it" |
The SBA describes the cash flow method as a way to see how much of a loan the business can support, which is not the same as a sale price, and the last two methods look at assets. The SBA calls these "a few" of the methods, so an appraiser may use others. For an owner, the lever this page focuses on is the profit the business makes and the confidence a buyer can have in it. This page does not give multiples or price ranges; a sale price depends on the business, the buyer and the deal.
What raises the value of a home service business?
Seven drivers, each one something you can see in your own books and operations.
| Driver | Why a buyer or lender cares | Where to see it in your business |
|---|---|---|
| Clean, reconciled books | Nothing else can be checked until the numbers can be trusted | Bank and card accounts reconciled each month; a profit and loss statement and balance sheet you can produce on request |
| Profit the books can show | Earnings-based methods start from it | Operating profit on the profit and loss statement, year after year |
| Revenue that repeats | Work already agreed for the months ahead is easier to count on | Revenue from service or maintenance agreements, tracked as its own line |
| A spread of customers | Losing one customer should not sink the year | Revenue by customer, and the share that comes from your largest few |
| An owner who is not in every job | A buyer pays for a business that runs without the seller | Who prices work, approves spending and manages the crew, and what stalls when you are away |
| Written systems | The way work gets done can be handed over | Written steps for estimating, scheduling, job close-out and the month-end close |
| Team and capacity | Growth needs people who can deliver it | Crew hours available against the work already booked |
What lowers it?
Mostly the same drivers run the other way, plus one warning sign in the bank account.
- Books that are behind or mixed with personal spending. A buyer cannot trust a profit figure they cannot trace.
- Profit that only shows up in good months. Earnings that swing are harder to count on than earnings that repeat.
- An owner at the center of everything. If every estimate, purchase and key customer runs through one person, that person is part of what is being sold.
- One customer who matters too much. A large share of revenue from one account is a risk a buyer will price in.
- Cash surprises. If a profitable business keeps running short of cash, a buyer will want to see where the cash went. Our page on profitable but no cash covers where cash goes that the profit and loss statement does not show.
Where should an owner start?
With the books, then the drivers, in this order.
- Get the books current and reconciled. Every later step depends on numbers you can trust, which is why clean books come before any CFO advice.
- Know the numbers that drive profit. Revenue by service, gross profit on each type of job, overhead, and the share of revenue that repeats or comes from your largest customers.
- Test the levers in a model. A financial model shows what a price change, a hire or a push on service agreements does to profit before you commit.
- Pick a few drivers for the year. Put them in the annual plan with an owner and a date, rather than working on all seven at once.
- Review every quarter. Check the drivers against the plan and move to the next one when a fix holds.
What does a value check look like?
A few shares worked out from your own records. This is an illustration with made-up figures, not a client's numbers.
| Check | Figure | Share of $2,000,000 revenue |
|---|---|---|
| Largest customer | $500,000 | 25% |
| Five largest customers | $900,000 | 45% |
| Service and maintenance agreements | $300,000 | 15% |
In this illustration a quarter of revenue comes from one account and less than a sixth repeats under agreements. Neither figure is good or bad on its own. They are starting points for questions: do the agreements renew, would they transfer to a new owner, and do they earn a profit? And what would the year look like if the largest customer left? The check does not put a price on the business.
How does Profit First fit in?
It makes setting profit aside a habit.
In Mike Michalowicz's Profit First, money is divided into separate accounts on set allocation days, with profit set aside first, as a percentage of what he calls Real Revenue: income after materials and subcontractors, without subtracting your own employees' wages. His advice for getting started: "Start small. Very small if necessary. Even 1% is enough to begin changing behavior." The Profit account is a record of cash set aside, not proof of earnings. A buyer starts from the profit and loss statement and may adjust the reported earnings, for example for what it would cost to replace the owner's work, to estimate what the business can keep earning under new ownership. What the habit changes is how the owner treats profit, as something planned rather than whatever is left. The Profit First page covers the method.
When is it time to get help?
When the biggest decisions are being made on gut feel and the bank balance.
Debbie names that pattern on her fractional CFO page: owners making the biggest calls in the business, "what to charge, who to hire, what to buy", on gut feel and the bank balance. Other signs she lists:
- You're not sure you can afford the next hire, so you guess.
- You're growing, but you're not actually keeping more.
If you are preparing an actual sale, a formal valuation is work for a qualified business appraiser, and the SBA suggests buyers consider hiring an attorney and an accountant. If your books are behind, start with bookkeeping.
How does Right Way Profits help with business value?
Through the Growth and Scale levels of its fractional CFO work, for founder-led service and trade businesses.
- Growth, roughly $3M to $15M a year: in Debbie's words, "exactly what your business is worth financially and what it would take to double it, with the specific drivers, targets, and scenarios that make the path real." That is her yardstick for planning; the published description does not call it a formal valuation or appraisal.
- Scale, roughly $15M to $50M a year: she describes the business building "genuine enterprise value", with "the documented systems, financial discipline, and organizational maturity" behind it, and the outcome as "A business worth more than its top line implies, built on systems, discipline, and organizational maturity that scale with or without the founder." The risks she lists at this level are tax exposure, covenant compliance, concentration risk and insurance gaps.
- Pricing: fractional CFO pricing is set on the call.
- Formal valuations: her published Growth and Scale descriptions cover business value for planning. They do not describe appraisals, brokering a sale or working with buyers, so for a formal valuation use a qualified business appraiser. The steps on this page are general practice.
The fractional CFO page for $3M to $15M businesses sets out the Growth level in full. Debbie DeKnight leads Right Way Profits and is a Master Certified Profit First Professional. The Profit First Professionals podcast page about her says she brings over 30 years of accounting experience and calls her a Profit First Master certified coach. For what clients say, read the client testimonials.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a home service business worth more?
Profit that a buyer or lender can count on without the current owner. In general terms that comes down to clean, reconciled books, profit the books can show year after year, revenue that repeats, such as service or maintenance agreements, no single customer the business depends on, and a team and written systems that keep work moving when the owner is away.
How is a small business valued?
There is more than one method. The U.S. Small Business Administration lists several used to set a fair price for a sale, including a capitalized earning approach, an excess earning method, a cash flow method, a tangible assets (balance sheet) method and a method that values specific intangible assets. The SBA calls these a few of the methods, so the list is not complete. Of the five, three start from earnings or cash flow, and the SBA describes the cash flow method as a way to see how much of a loan the business can support, which is not the same as a sale price. The other two look at tangible and intangible assets. A qualified business appraiser can say which approach fits a given business.
Does depending on the owner lower a business's value?
It can. If the owner prices every job, approves every purchase and holds the customer relationships, a buyer has to ask what is left when the owner leaves. Moving those jobs to people and written systems makes the business easier to hand over.
Do I need to be planning a sale to work on value?
No. The things that make a business worth more to a buyer, such as reliable profit, clean books and less reliance on the owner, also make it easier to run, plan and grow while you own it.
Who should value my business if I want to sell?
A formal valuation for a sale is work for a qualified business appraiser, and the SBA suggests buyers consider hiring an attorney and an accountant for the deal. Right Way Profits does not publish appraisal or brokerage services; its fractional CFO work looks at what the business is worth financially as a planning yardstick.
Does Right Way Profits help increase business value?
Its fractional CFO work covers it in two levels. The Growth level, for businesses of about $3M to $15M a year, includes understanding "exactly what your business is worth financially and what it would take to double it". The Scale level, for about $15M to $50M, describes the business building "genuine enterprise value". Debbie DeKnight leads Right Way Profits, which serves founder-led service and trade businesses across the US. Fractional CFO pricing is set on the call.
Want the business to be worth more next year than it is today?
Book a 45-minute discovery call. At the end you will know whether Debbie can help.
Keep going
Where to next
- All services
- Fractional CFO
- Profit First
- Bookkeeping
- The Profit Revolution course
- Bookkeeper vs accountant vs fractional CFO
- Profitable on paper, broke in the bank
- Cash flow forecasting for service businesses
- Financial modeling and annual planning
- How working together works
- How to choose a fractional CFO
- Certified Profit First Professionals, explained
- Fractional CFO for $1M to $3M businesses
- Fractional CFO for $3M to $15M businesses
- Fractional CFO for home service businesses
- Fractional CFO for HVAC companies
- Fractional CFO for plumbing companies
- Remote bookkeeping with a monthly close
- Bookkeeping for trades businesses
- Profit First for contractors
- Profit First for HVAC and plumbing companies
- Podcast interviews with Debbie
- Blog
- About Debbie DeKnight
- Client testimonials
- Contact